Seasonal cooking from the pond house kitchen.
All recipes Breakfast & Brunch Soups & Stews Salads & Grain Bowls Pasta & Noodles Pizza & Flatbreads Burgers & Sandwiches Seafood Poultry Beef & Pork Vegetarian & Vegan Rice & Grains Asian Stir-Fry Mexican & Latin Mediterranean Indian Baking & Bread Desserts & Sweets Cakes & Pastries Drinks & Smoothies Grilling & BBQ
Home / Burgers & Sandwiches / Pan-Seared Reuben Sandwich
Burgers & Sandwiches · Free

Pan-Seared Reuben Sandwich

Weeknight-friendly Pan-Seared Reuben Sandwich with real depth of flavor.

Rating4.3 ★
Total time50 min
Serves6
LevelEasy
Prep 20 min · Cook 30 min · 791 reviews
Juicy cheeseburger with fries served on a plate, surrounded by a cozy setting.

Method

  1. Gather and prep everything first: brioche buns, cheddar, mayonnaise and set within reach of the stove.
  2. Set a wide pan over medium heat and sweat the yellow onion in a little butter until translucent.
  3. Add the reuben and let it pan-seared, undisturbed, so it takes on real color before you stir.
  4. Stir in the cheddar along with a good pinch of salt, scraping up anything stuck to the bottom of the pan.
  5. Pour in the coconut milk, bring to a gentle simmer, and cook until thickened and glossy.
  6. Off the heat, brighten it up with a spoonful of yogurt and a final crack of pepper.
  7. Serve warm, ideally with something to soak up the sauce.
Cooked this one? Ratings and notes help other members — this recipe is currently rated 4.3 from 791 cooks.
More

From Burgers & Sandwiches

See all →